Chapter 3: The Religion
It’s called Satan in the Smoke, or Face in the Smoke depending on your religious beliefs.
—————–
“I know without a shadow of a doubt that your picture is a sign from our God and Creator that He indeed was present that horrific day to gather His people back into Him.” – Email message
BY MARK D PHILLIPS
Chapter 3 – The Religion
Emails came from all over. This was what is now called a viral experience. 2001 predated social networks. Email was our social network.
The overwhelming response to Satan in the Smoke was emotional. The base feelings that flowed through email messages is that religion had to be involved. How otherwise, could the rational mind accept the image?
Each person who emailed me with their religious views had already made a connection in their mind. My background in religion is diversified.
My father had been raised Baptist, my mother a Catholic. Though I was not a member of any denomination, I had visited nearly every church there was. I have my beliefs. They are my own and I wasn’t going to open myself to the debate going on in the email messages sent to me. It was a battle I knew I would never win.
I tried to rationalize the event. Was Al Queda the Devil’s sword? How could a benevolent God allow this to happen to his children? Or was it all just Man acting as Man does.
The myriad views presented were so forceful and so assured. Everyone knew exactly what the photograph meant in his or her own religious sphere. Email allowed many people to express intense feelings.
The Internet is a voyeuristic way to communicate inner feelings. The very nature of communication in a totally virtual, anonymous environment let’s the individual say things to a stranger that they probably wouldn’t even say to a family member. I received in excess of 30,000 messages related to the image and the feelings the image brought forth in viewing.
Many of the messages talked of the tribulation and the fears of the battles between heaven and hell. Hundreds quoted bible verses and many used their messages to question their own beliefs, or as a way to reinforce them.
“I cannot for one minute believe that a satanic presence would overshadow the presence of God during this catastrophe. I know without a shadow of a doubt that your picture is a sign from our God and Creator that He indeed was present that horrific day to gather His people back into Him. The face I see in your picture is the Lions face depicted in the Bible from the four living creatures. The King of Judah, the Lion of Judah was there present triumphing over evil. No that was no devil that day but our Lord and God and Saviour. You have proof in your picture.”
—-Cottage Grove, Oregon
The more I read, the more I began to question my own feelings regarding the photograph. At times it was hard to accept the outpouring from the public, especially messages stating “God had placed me on the earth for this one moment in time.”
Writers wanted to credit me with doing God’s work by providing answers to their innermost fears. In a land of many religions, the overwhelming number of messages mentioned Christian beliefs. Clergy used the photograph in their services, asking to print it out and distribute the photograph in their ministerial efforts.
Hello, I’m from upstate New York. My son, however, lives in Brooklyn and witnessed the second bombing take place at the World Trade Center. I must say, I was quite petrified when I couldn’t reach him to see if he was ok. He, on the other hand, was able to get to the phone and call me a little after 12:00PM. His was the sweetest voice I could have ever heard! I cried, not just for him because he was safe, but for the thousands of innocent lives that were lost to such an evil force.
I am a newly ordained Minister, and I found it so very difficult to speak comforting words after seeing the disaster on television. Now, after a week has passed, and we have seen the devistation in the faces of the crews working so feverishly to try to find some semblance of life amidst the rubble, my thoughts are not of fear. My thoughts are that of hope. We have seen a city turn around and see each other for the first time…helping each other as though their lives depended upon it. This is rich, this is love, this is God at work against evil. What better way to defeat the enemy!
Now when we, as a nation, hear the words being sung… “God Bless America”…, we know that they are more than just words now. They are the heart of the country…the hope that we can survive, and the strength of the love to bring us together as a strong, powerful nation…”with liberty and justice for all!” It is our home, and we need to be proud of it.
So, Mark, if you would like to share this letter with others, feel free. May you not be haunted by the scenes you have seen, but rather have renewed hope that we, as a nation, will rise again and stand with feet firmly planted in the ground, and with every breath we take, may it make us strong in mind, soul and body.
God Bless you,
Reverend Mary
The debate over good and evil was intense. Message after message stated the belief that there must be a devil if there is a God. But many questioned how we as humans actually knew what the devil looks like. Perception is always the key.
We have grown up in a society that shows the devil with horns and a pitchfork. This image has been passed down through history, and unfortunately, enforced in our mind’s eye by entertainment and art, not to mention Halloween.
The fact that the image contains such a shape is inexplicable. It is smoke and light. One writer put it correctly, stating “maybe we are projecting that image mentally because we need to feel that there is some evil beyond our control. A belief in God necessitates a believe in the Devil as the evil force in the world and it does exist. Our eyes see what our brain feels it needs to see.”
Across the southern Bible belt, feelings are strongly skewed toward the belief that evil is the “Devil” and good is “God.” For myself, I can never forget the sermons at my Grandfather’s church in Graham County, North Carolina. There was never any question that the devil was evil incarnate. The devil seemed very real when you were eight years old.
All through my childhood the icon for the devil was the same. If I believed everything that I was taught as a child, how can I question what the image contains?
I began to feel like I was trapped in an ongoing Baptist revival. Each new email was a religious sermon.
“If I were you I would feel privileged (unfortunately) that the Lord used you to shed “the Light” on darkness,” wrote Beth P. in her email. “The faith of Islam is rebellion towards God that goes way back and what better way to divide people on this earth than to use “religion”. Thanks for letting Him use you !!!”
These same thoughts came to me as I talked to radio DJ’s and callers to their shows. Most Americans have very little contact outside of their religions. My father left North Carolina as an 18-year-old, joining the Air Force to escape the rural life of the mountains. His experiences during that time shaped a great deal of my own life.
Imagine going from Robbinsville, North Carolina, where God was defined by the fundamental Baptist religion, to Tokyo, Japan. My father’s eyes were opened to different possibilities. Upon his return, he met and married my mother in Chicopee, Massachusetts. Raised Catholic, my mother brought a totally different dynamic into my childhood. I often say, we tried them all – Episcopal, Methodist, Baptist, Unitarian, Presbyterian, Catholic, and all christian.
All the religions seemed the same in a young child’s eyes. Only when I reached my teens and 20’s did I start questioning much of what I had learned within the system. Much like my father, I began traveling as a young photographer and discovered that there were many different religions than the Christian ones I had been a part of.
For the first time, I had contact with other religions. I never knew the differences, and there were many that I did not even realize existed. I had my first interaction with Judaism as a young staff photographer in Augusta, Georgia. I was 25. I did not know what Hanukkah was. I photographed a family on the first night and was transfixed by the beauty of their faith.
When I met Andrea Peyser in Florida, and we began dating, Judaism entered my life on a personal level. And now with a daughter, we are carrying on many of the traditions. Personally, I see no problem with combining multiple religions within one family.
When I visited Israel with Andrea, I will never forget walking the streets of Jerusalem and meeting people from each of the religions predominate within the city. I did not feel an undercurrent of hatred. I felt an acceptance that transcended the individual beliefs. Granted it was a simpler time, but Intifada had occurred. As an American tourist, we felt accepted by all.
Now, we are told that Israel is the devil incarnate by a left-wing movement in America.
The attacks of September 11 and everything that has occurred since have created a completely new world. Our generation was blessed with peace. My generation missed the Vietnam War and was too old for the Gulf War.
I travelled to many corners of the world and never came across the type of hatred that led to the attack on the World Trade Center.
In Israel and Egypt, people were always people. Shortly after Andrea and I visited Cairo, an attack occurred on tourists at both the hotel we stayed in and at the Cairo Museum. It was one of the first times I realized how the radical religions could affect my life. It struck home even more after the first attack on the World Trade Center.
We heard over and over again how “lucky” America was to not suffer from terrorism. We have had our share. The first bombing of the World Trade Center was a horrible event.
I was one of the few journalists allowed into the garage to see the devastation wrought by the explosion. It was a miracle that more people were not killed. The bomb destroyed four floors of the underground parking garage, leaving a hole that stretched wall to wall with crushed vehicles barely visible in the rubble.
Six people were killed, over 1,000 were injured and it took hours to evacuate the 50,000 people from the complex.
The discovery of a Vehicle Identification Number on a piece of the rental van used for the bombing led to a rental contract with the terrorists names. They were quickly captured. Their trail led straight to Islamic extremists living in Jersey City, New Jersey, where all but one of the suspects were followers of Sheik Abdel Rahman at his storefront mosque. The sheik would be charged with helping the group in their plans. Standing outside his home in Jersey City, I photographed his arrest by the FBI. In their neighborhood, I felt far removed from the streets of Manhattan and a hatred that frightened me. I was threatened, I was screamed at, I was called names for being there and taking photographs. It was pure hatred.
We have seen other events that have changed America. The Oklahoma City bombing was domestic terrorism. Shootings everywhere that may not be designated terror, but are. In my mind, it does not matter who actually does it. Whether it is religion or politics, it all has the same results. Innocents die for what someone thinks is a statement.
Hatred is hatred no matter what people claim as the root issue. Because I believe differently than you should not be a reason for murder.
The first time I traveled to South Africa, I learned about tribalism. It affects as much as religion, if not more. When you get right down to it, they are almost one in the same. In America, we have many definitions for our people – What part of the country you are from, where your ancestors arrived from, and what religion you are.
As the world grows smaller, we learn more about each other. The different religions, different tribes, and different values should not be as much of an unknown. The instantaneous media spreads information. It is up to us to learn and hopefully become more understanding and knowledgeable of the differences in individuals.
“IS IT REAL?” Satan In The Smoke, 9/11 by Mark D Phillip
Chapter 1: THE DAY, 9/11
Chapter 2 – Is Seeing Believing?
Chapter 3 – The Religion